Report on the capzise and sinking of the workboat Heidi in Sandebukta 16 February 2015

Marine report 2016/04

The workboat Heidi was used by the company OPD in the work with flushing of underwater-tubes. While awaiting a new mooring for this operation the boat took in water, capzised and foundered at 3 meters. The 3 persons on board rescued themselves and were not injured in the accident. The AIBN investigation has shown that OPD had not prepared any stability calculations for the boat based on established stability standards. Consequently, a description giving the crew information about the operational limitations were absent.

The mooring line broke while the workboat Heidi prepared for a diving operation in Bjerkøysundet on 16 February 2015. While waiting for a new mooring arrangement, the diving leader ran the boat slowly back and forth in the area with/against the waves in a circle formed pattern and conducted a starboard turn in each end.

The Accident Investigation Board Norway (AIBN) stability calculations show that the total deck cargo carried on board on the day of the accident made the stability of the boat marginal. Because of unsatisfactory bilging of observed bottom water, there was water in the hull at the time of departure in the morning. The low freeboard in the front allowed water from waves and ripples against the bow to come on to the deck. This led to water ingress in the hull from i.e. corrosion in air intake on deck and leaky deck-hatches. In practice this caused the absence of stability and stability-reserve for the boat. Supplied with an inclining energy from the use of the rudder, together with sideway displacement of bottom water, lead to capsizing and foundering.

The investigation has shown that the company OPD had not prepared any stability calculations for the boat based on established stability standards. The load limit of 6 tons, which was fixed by the company with background in information from the previous owner and from their own experience with freight of a 6 tons heavy excavator as deck cargo on board the workboat, resulted in marginal stability independent of any stability standard.

Consequently, a description giving the crew information about the operational limitations were absent. In addition the maintenance of the boat had deficiencies. The AIBN considers that this in total indicate deficiencies in the management of the boat safety in the company.

Please note: The full report is in Norwegian only.

Safety recommendation

Safety recommendation MARINE no. 2016/02T

The workboat Heidi was used in operations with an unjustifiable small stability reserve. This contributed to the capsizing and shipwrecking on 16 February 2015. The company OPD had not prepared stability calculations for the workboat based on established stability standards, and documentation giving the crew on board information about the operational limitations were missing.

The AIBN recommends that the company OPD have stability calculations prepared for their boats giving the crew information about operational limitations.

Safety recommendation MARINE no. 2016/03T

The company OPD were missing stability calculations and descriptions of the operational limitations for the workboat Heidi, which capsized and shipwrecked on 16. February 2015. In addition the maintenance of the boat had deficiencies. The AIBN considers that this in total indicate deficiencies in the management of the boat safety in the company.

The AIBN recommends that the company OPD review its internal routines for maritime operation in order to ensure better management of their boat safety operation.

Facts

Location Sandebukta in Vestfold county
Occurrence date 16.02.2015
Accident category Foundering
Area Norwegian Territorial Waters
Name of vessel Heidi
Accident type Capsize
Vessel type Special Purpose Ship
Register The Norwegian Ship Register

Reports - same area

Reports same accident category